Sen. Mike Lee calls FBI action “a breach of trust,” and a “violation of the Constitution”

Estimated read time: 2-3
minutes

WASHINGTON — A bipartisan team of lawmakers has introduced new legislation intended to curb the FBI’s sweeping surveillance powers, saying the bill helps close the loopholes that allow officials to seize Americans’ data without a warrant.

The bill follows more than a decade of debate over post-Sept. 11, 2001, surveillance powers that allow domestic law enforcement to, without a warrant, scan the vast mountains of data gathered by America’s foreign surveillance apparatus.

The reforms introduced Tuesday reflect discomfort over the practice of warrantless scans, which are authorized under Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. Its opponents were galvanized when the Office of Director of National Intelligence revealed in July that the FBI had improperly conducted searches for information about a U.S. senator and two state officials.

Utah Sen. Mike Lee, of the bill’s co-sponsors, said that kind of thing was more than just a mistake.

“When the FBI snoops on the American people without a warrant, it’s not a blunder, it’s a breach of trust and it’s a violation of the Constitution,” Lee told reporters.

Reforms in the proposed legislation include putting limits on searches of Americans’ communications without judicial authorization and a prohibition of so-called “backdoor” searches which invoke foreign intelligence justifications to spy on Americans.

“We’re introducing a bill that protects both Americans’ security and Americans’ liberty,” Sen. Oregon Ron Wyden — a Democrat and a longtime critic of government surveillance — said at a press conference on Tuesday.

Other sponsors of the bill include Republican Rep. Warren Davidson and Democrat Rep. Zoe Lofgren, as well as more than a dozen other senators and representatives.

The White House and the FBI did not immediately return messages seeking comment, although executive branch officials have long insisted that the surveillance power — which expires at the end of the year — is a critical tool for fighting foreign espionage and terrorism and have lobbied for its reauthorization.

Most recent Politics stories